Lynas Rare Earths has been positioned as a cornerstone of Western strategy to break China’s dominance in critical minerals. However, recent investigative reporting has cast doubt on this narrative, sending ripples of concern through investment circles. The fundamental premise driving Lynas’s valuation—that it can provide meaningful supply chain independence—now faces serious scrutiny.
Investigative Report Questions Core Assumptions
The source of market unease stems from a detailed Washington Post investigation that directly challenges the “China independence” thesis central to Lynas’s investment appeal. According to the report, China continues to control approximately 90% of rare earths processing capacity worldwide. More troubling for investors is the assertion that Chinese influence remains substantial even at supposedly alternative production sites, including Lynas’s Malaysian operations.
Particularly vulnerable to this scrutiny are Lynas’s expansion plans in the United States. The report amplifies management’s own concerns about “significant uncertainties” surrounding the proposed processing facility in Seadrift, Texas. While markets had previously priced in rapid growth projections, the actual progress on U.S.-backed projects is now being characterized as sluggish.
Market Reaction Defies Analyst Optimism
The timing presents a striking contrast to recent analyst sentiment. Just days before the report emerged, UBS analysts had reaffirmed their buy rating on Lynas shares with increased price targets, citing growing global demand for rare earth elements. Yet the market has largely disregarded this optimistic assessment, instead focusing squarely on execution risks.
Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying Lynas?
This divergence between analyst confidence and operational realities has introduced fresh volatility. After failing to maintain recent gains, Lynas shares closed the week at €8.27. Investors appear to be assigning greater weight to geopolitical bottlenecks than to long-term potential.
Critical Week Ahead for Investor Confidence
The coming week represents a pivotal moment for Lynas management. All attention turns to the annual general meeting scheduled for Wednesday, November 26, where executives face mounting pressure to address fundamental concerns.
Three critical questions demand clarification: Is there a definitive timeline and secured funding for the Texas refinery? What is the true stability of the operating license in Malaysia? How will the company manage costs amid delayed progress? Until management provides satisfactory answers to these concerns, uncertainty will likely continue to influence share price performance.
Ad
Lynas Stock: Buy or Sell?! New Lynas Analysis from January 11 delivers the answer:
The latest Lynas figures speak for themselves: Urgent action needed for Lynas investors. Is it worth buying or should you sell? Find out what to do now in the current free analysis from January 11.
Lynas: Buy or sell? Read more here...
