ServiceNow’s finance chief has pushed back hard on the idea that artificial intelligence will cannibalize enterprise software demand, arguing that companies need clear rules and guardrails before they can deploy the technology at scale. Gina Mastantuono’s case rests on control rather than capability: she is not questioning what AI can do, but stressing what it takes to run it inside a large organization.
That argument runs straight into a wall of market skepticism. CNBC attributed the stock’s post-earnings slide to both the quarterly figures and fears about AI competition, and Mastantuono’s remarks target that second pressure point directly.
The shares were down 3.2% on Friday, caught in a broader retreat across technology names. Reuters linked the selloff to worries that heavy spending on AI infrastructure may not generate adequate returns anytime soon. For holders, that leaves a concrete question: does the operating growth justify carrying this extra layer of valuation risk?
Two separate uncertainties are colliding. ServiceNow has to deliver on its own business targets, while sentiment toward tech stocks hinges on whether investors find the economic payoff from AI spending convincing. Solid company numbers alone may not be enough to steady the price.
The counter-case has numbers behind it
ServiceNow can point to its AI bookings as evidence. Net new contract value in the AI business climbed 65% year over year in the third quarter of 2026, and at Wednesday’s presentation the company raised its full-year AI contract value target to $1.7 billion.
That shows demand for ServiceNow’s AI offerings. It does not yet answer how competition from new entrants will affect the rest of the business over the long run.
The company also cites productivity gains from its own internal AI use. On the quarterly call, management tied a gradual reduction in total headcount to internal AI deployment. As reported yesterday, CEO Bill McDermott stressed that no layoffs had been announced. Mastantuono put annualized efficiency gains from the company’s own AI products at more than $1 billion — a figure whose calculation was not disclosed and which has not been independently verified. Investors should treat it as a company statement, not an audited contribution to results.
Staffing is being managed selectively. ServiceNow is limiting hiring in certain support functions while continuing to add in growth areas. The number of quota-carrying sales staff rose, even as headcount in the sales organization fell significantly.
A rival is circling the same budgets
Competition is building at the same time. One provider is targeting enterprise customers and automation budgets across IT, HR and operational functions.
So two trends sit side by side: ServiceNow reports growing AI contracts and internal efficiency gains, while new vendors go after the very budgets the company is pitching for. Mastantuono’s defense offers a clear strategic position. Whether it holds up economically will be decided by customer demand and contract development — not by the general need for AI guardrails.
Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying ServiceNow?
The cRPO guide is the real test
The number that matters most is the announced slowdown in cRPO growth. ServiceNow said Thursday it expects an 18.5% increase for the closing quarter. In the third quarter of 2026, currency-adjusted growth was still 21%.
That is not a decline in the business — it is a slower pace of expansion, and the distinction matters for anyone weighing the stock. Betting on a recovery means judging whether the lower momentum is already priced in. The share price drop alone cannot answer that.
The operating base remains substantial: subscription revenue came in at $3,988 million for the third quarter of 2026, with total revenue of $4,106 million. Those figures show the scale of the existing business. What counts more for a re-rating is how its growth develops. The next operating checkpoint is therefore the actual cRPO performance in the closing quarter against the guided rate.
Subscription revenue rose 21% year over year in the third quarter, with total revenue up 20.5%. The business is growing, not standing still — though that does not guarantee a share price recovery. The bullish case is narrower: if operating performance stays resilient, current skepticism may be running ahead of what the business trajectory justifies.
Analysts trimmed targets without abandoning ship
The analyst reaction was not uniformly negative. Citigroup cut its price target to $157 on Thursday, and TD Cowen to $160. Both firms kept their buy ratings.
That combination — lower targets, positive recommendations — carries more signal than any single price target. Both houses reduced expectations without giving up their fundamental view. It is not proof the adjustment process is over; it shows they still see opportunity despite trimmed forecasts.
The bear case has two entry points. Actual growth could come in below guidance. Or persistent doubts about the returns on heavy AI spending could keep weighing on the tech sector even if ServiceNow hits its own marks. Reuters reported Thursday that ServiceNow’s results and Fortinet’s outlook had pressured software stocks, with concerns about AI displacement again at the center.
That fear is distinct from the question of when infrastructure investment pays off. Both can press on valuations at once. For ServiceNow, the result is a demanding backdrop: hitting operating targets might prevent disappointment without sparking fresh confidence.
As long as the company meets its guided cRPO trajectory, the case for stabilization through resilient growth remains coherent. If momentum falls short of its own forecast, that would reinforce fears of a sharper slowdown. The next concrete operating catalyst is confirmation or a miss on the closing-quarter guidance. Meanwhile, faith in the economic returns from AI investment stays a swing factor for the wider market. A lower share price on its own does not settle the question.
Ad
ServiceNow Stock: Buy or Sell?! New ServiceNow Analysis from November 1 delivers the answer:
The latest ServiceNow figures speak for themselves: Urgent action needed for ServiceNow investors. Is it worth buying or should you sell? Find out what to do now in the current free analysis from November 1.
ServiceNow: Buy or sell? Read more here...
