Shares of Lynas Rare Earths Ltd. have been among the standout performers this year. However, the company’s operational momentum has hit a snag due to persistent infrastructure issues at its newest processing facility in Western Australia. The situation presents a critical test: whether this is a temporary production hiccup or a sign of a deeper structural vulnerability, especially as the market balances high commodity prices against these operational headwinds.
Infrastructure Woes Trigger Production Shortfall
The core issue stems from confirmed power supply instability in the Goldfields region. Lynas’s Kalgoorlie Rare Earths Processing Facility, which was expected to ramp up smoothly, instead faced significant disruptions throughout November and early December. The company attributes these challenges to weaknesses in the local electricity grid.
Management estimates the production loss at Kalgoorlie equates to roughly one month’s output for the current quarter. The impact extends far beyond the local site. This facility is responsible for producing Mixed Rare Earth Carbonate (MREC), a crucial feedstock for Lynas’s downstream separation plant in Malaysia. Consequently, any shortfall in Kalgoorlie creates a bottleneck across the entire supply chain.
In response, the company is urgently evaluating off-grid power solutions to gain greater independence from the regional network. The disruptions have already prompted downward revisions to near-term earnings expectations. Recent share price action indicates the market is taking these pressures seriously, though currently viewing them as a transient obstacle.
The stock, trading at 7.02 euros, remains well below its 52-week high of 13.15 euros reached in October. After a powerful rally earlier in the year, a noticeable consolidation phase has taken hold.
Analyst Confidence Endures Amid Operational Setbacks
Despite the immediate challenges, analysts at UBS have reaffirmed their bullish stance. The investment bank maintains a “Buy” rating with a price target of 17.70 Australian dollars. Their optimism is rooted in Lynas’s unique strategic position as the only large-scale producer of separated rare earths outside of China—a significant advantage in an era of geopolitical tensions and supply chain diversification.
UBS analysts cite several factors supporting their continued confidence:
Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying Lynas?
- Favorable Commodity Pricing: Prices for Neodymium-Praseodymium (NdPr), essential for magnets in electric vehicles and wind turbines, have strengthened notably. A marked increase in Chinese spot prices was observed in early December.
- Significant Barriers to Entry: The complex technology, stringent regulatory approvals, and substantial capital required to operate in this sector protect Lynas’s established market position from new competitors.
- Projected Earnings Growth: From the 2026 financial year onward, analysts anticipate a material acceleration in profits, driven by planned capacity expansions at both the Mt Weld mine and the Malaysian processing operations.
The UBS perspective underscores a view that the short-term production dip does not alter the long-term investment narrative, provided the company can resolve its operational issues.
A Year of Contrasts: Record Gains Meet Supply Chain Reality
The current difficulties emerge following a period of exceptional share price performance for Lynas. Starting from a weak base early in the year, the equity surged through 2025, peaking in mid-October before undergoing a significant correction. Despite this pullback, the stock still shows a year-to-date gain of approximately 78% in euro terms, vastly outperforming the broader market.
This performance reflects a fundamental shift in global supply chain priorities. Western governments are actively supporting projects that reduce reliance on Chinese suppliers for critical minerals, positioning Lynas as a key vehicle for “resource security.”
Simultaneously, the Kalgoorlie bottleneck highlights a challenge of rapid expansion: dependence on a single transmission line has proven to be a vulnerability. Infrastructure reliability, therefore, remains a central risk factor, even amid strong demand and supportive pricing.
Looking Ahead: Quarterly Report to Provide Crucial Clarity
The next significant milestone will be the quarterly production report due in January. This update will quantify the financial impact of the power outages on revenue and earnings. Investor focus will center on three key areas:
1. Potential decisions regarding on-site power generation at Kalgoorlie.
2. The ongoing trajectory of NdPr prices.
3. The company’s ability to reconcile operational stability with its ambitious expansion roadmap.
For 2026, the core investment thesis remains intact from an analytical standpoint. Strategic scarcity in rare earths, pricing power, and capacity growth are still seen as primary value drivers. However, the market’s continued belief in this story now heavily depends on Lynas’s ability to swiftly mitigate its infrastructure vulnerabilities and return production to a predictable, steady-state operation.
Ad
Lynas Stock: Buy or Sell?! New Lynas Analysis from December 17 delivers the answer:
The latest Lynas figures speak for themselves: Urgent action needed for Lynas investors. Is it worth buying or should you sell? Find out what to do now in the current free analysis from December 17.
Lynas: Buy or sell? Read more here...
