PayPal finds itself at a pivotal moment as CEO Alex Chriss delivers unexpectedly stark warnings during what should be the company’s strongest quarter. Speaking at Wednesday’s Citi FinTech Conference, Chriss highlighted concerning consumer behavior shifts that threaten fourth-quarter performance. With shares already under significant pressure, investors now question whether the holiday season will bring disaster or if the company’s strategic pivot can salvage results.
Strategic Shift Amid Core Business Challenges
The payments giant is navigating turbulent waters as its traditional checkout business faces headwinds. Chriss observed noticeable changes in consumer spending patterns emerging in mid-September, particularly among middle and lower-income segments. While higher-income consumers continue using credit cards freely, budget-conscious shoppers are pulling back—creating direct pressure on PayPal’s fundamental transaction processing operations.
Against this backdrop, the CEO anticipates Q4 will deliver slower growth compared to the third quarter’s performance. This timing couldn’t be more delicate, given the crucial holiday shopping period’s importance to annual results.
Buy Now, Pay Later Emerges as Growth Engine
PayPal’s response centers on accelerating its Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL) offerings, which Chriss characterizes as representing a “generational shift” from traditional credit toward flexible payment plans. Recent performance metrics support this strategic emphasis:
- BNPL transaction volume increased by 20% during the third quarter
- Active BNPL accounts grew by 20% over the same period
- Younger users particularly are driving adoption of these payment alternatives
Landmark KKR Agreement Reshapes Capital Strategy
Just two days before the conference, on November 17, PayPal announced a transformative arrangement with investment firm KKR. The agreement enables KKR funds to purchase up to €65 billion in European BNPL loan receivables from PayPal. This strategic move allows substantial expansion of the BNPL business without burdening the company’s balance sheet, simultaneously freeing capital for other strategic investments.
Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying PayPal?
Chriss emphasized the company’s strengthened position, stating PayPal is “fundamentally stronger today than two years ago.” After years of negative trends, transaction margins are projected to expand by 6-7% in 2025—a significant turnaround for this previously problematic metric.
Market Experts Express Cautious Outlook
Financial analysts remain divided in their assessments. Among 37 covering analysts, 15 maintain “Buy” ratings, while 18 recommend “Hold” positions and four advise selling shares. This cautious sentiment reflects broader market uncertainty about whether BNPL growth can sufficiently offset declines in the core processing business.
The true test arrives with upcoming Q4 earnings results. Previous 2025 guidance projected adjusted earnings per share between $5.35 and $5.39, though Chriss indicated the lower end of this range now appears more realistic following recent consumer behavior changes.
The coming months will determine whether PayPal’s strategic bets can navigate through current challenges or if warning signs will escalate into more substantial concerns for investors.
Ad
PayPal Stock: Buy or Sell?! New PayPal Analysis from November 20 delivers the answer:
The latest PayPal figures speak for themselves: Urgent action needed for PayPal investors. Is it worth buying or should you sell? Find out what to do now in the current free analysis from November 20.
PayPal: Buy or sell? Read more here...
