Market sentiment toward PayPal has soured significantly following a wave of analyst downgrades and revised outlooks. The core concerns center on decelerating growth in its primary business segments and intensifying competition from nimble financial technology rivals. Although management is pursuing a strategic pivot by seeking a banking license, investor skepticism regarding near-term prospects currently dominates the trading narrative.
Analyst Targets Slashed Amid Slowing Momentum
The immediate catalyst for the renewed pressure was an analysis from Mizuho Securities. The investment bank reduced its price target for the payments giant from $84 to $75. While the firm maintained its “Outperform” rating, the rationale was sobering. Analysts pointed to recent commentary from PayPal’s Chief Financial Officer, which indicated a markedly weaker business dynamic heading into the fourth quarter.
This prompted drastic cuts to key performance metrics:
- Branded Checkout Growth: Expectations for this crucial segment were lowered from 4% to just 1%.
- Venmo Volume: The growth forecast for “Pay with Venmo” volume was adjusted down to 40% from 45%.
- Transaction Margin Dollar Growth: The projection was more than halved, falling from 5% to 2%.
These revisions align with management’s early December warnings that growth in branded checkout would be notably slower than in the third quarter.
Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying PayPal?
Strategic Gambit: The Banking License Play
In a long-term bid to stabilize its margins, PayPal has formally applied to establish a “PayPal Bank.” By operating as an Industrial Loan Company (ILC), the firm could eventually offer direct loans to small businesses and hold customer deposits, reducing its reliance on external banking partners.
The market’s reaction to this strategic shift has been tepid. Investors are currently assigning greater weight to the visible cooling in the core transaction business than to the potential long-term benefits of a banking charter. Furthermore, the path to obtaining and operating under such a license carries execution risk and invites stricter regulatory oversight.
Competitive Erosion and Technical Weakness
The gloomy outlook is compounded by the contrasting performance of competitors. As PayPal contends with single-digit growth, providers of “Buy Now, Pay Later” services, such as Affirm, are posting significant share price gains. Morgan Stanley analysts recently highlighted an “Innovator’s Dilemma” at PayPal, downgrading the stock to “Underweight.” They anticipate only modest transaction margin growth through 2028.
These fundamental worries are clearly reflected in the stock’s technical picture. Trading at €50.94, the shares hover just above their 52-week low of €50.41. A staggering year-to-date decline of over 39% demonstrates that the market is not yet viewing PayPal as a buying opportunity, despite its seemingly attractive price-to-earnings ratio of around 12. Without a decisive reversal in transaction volume trends, the equity is likely to remain under pressure.
Ad
PayPal Stock: Buy or Sell?! New PayPal Analysis from December 23 delivers the answer:
The latest PayPal figures speak for themselves: Urgent action needed for PayPal investors. Is it worth buying or should you sell? Find out what to do now in the current free analysis from December 23.
PayPal: Buy or sell? Read more here...
