Newmont Mining’s equity has emerged as one of the top performers in the mining sector this year, boasting a gain exceeding 100% since January. However, this powerful rally has now given way to significant uncertainty regarding the stock’s future trajectory. Despite a stellar fundamental backdrop driven by gold prices, a growing chorus of analysts is raising alarms over what they perceive as an overheated valuation. Investors currently find themselves caught between the temptation to secure profits and the lure of fresh buy recommendations.
Fundamental Strength Meets Valuation Concerns
The operational engine behind Newmont’s success continues to be the historically strong price of gold. For the third quarter of 2025, the company reported earnings per share of $1.71, soundly beating analyst estimates of $1.27. Revenue climbed to $5.52 billion, supported by an average realized gold price of $3,539 per ounce.
This financial performance generated a substantial free cash flow of $1.6 billion for the company, which is being directed toward debt reduction and strategic investments. On the operational front, Newmont also announced the commencement of commercial production at its Ahafo North project in Ghana. Market observers have further noted that the company is exploring options to fully consolidate its Nevada assets, which are currently managed within a joint venture structure.
A Clear Split in Expert Opinion
Perhaps the most pressing issue for the investment community is the stark divergence of opinion among leading analysts. BNP Paribas Exane recently drew attention by downgrading the stock from “Outperform” to a “Neutral” rating. The firm simultaneously reduced its price target from $107 to $97 per share. This move signals the analysts’ belief that the stock’s massive gains through 2025 may have already captured most of its near-term upside potential.
Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying Newmont Mining?
In a nearly simultaneous and directly contradictory move, Macquarie upgraded its stance on Newmont. The investment house moved its rating from “Hold” to a “Strong Buy”. This open disagreement highlights the current market dichotomy: mounting valuation worries on one side, and an exceptionally robust fundamental environment on the other.
Institutional Investors Rotate Positions
This split in analyst sentiment is mirrored by the actions of major institutional investors, contributing to increased market volatility. Recent activity shows a clear pattern of profit-taking by some large holders. European asset manager Amundi, for instance, reduced its stake in Newmont by 37.3 percent, selling over 4.7 million shares. This suggests certain large-scale investors are capitalizing on the elevated share price to lock in gains.
Concurrently, significant new capital is flowing into the stock. Norges Bank has reportedly established a new position valued at approximately $919 million, while Invesco Ltd. increased its holdings by 45 percent. This rotation from profit-takers to new buyers underscores the sustained, high-level interest in Newmont. The shares currently trade around €77.30, placing them roughly 8 percent below their 52-week high.
The prevailing market dynamic is characterized by this capital rotation. Long-term investors are securing profits following the impressive rally, while new institutional money bets on the enduring gold cycle. The path forward for the share price will now depend critically on whether the company’s record-breaking fundamental performance can consistently outweigh the market’s heightened valuation concerns.
Ad
Newmont Mining Stock: Buy or Sell?! New Newmont Mining Analysis from December 6 delivers the answer:
The latest Newmont Mining figures speak for themselves: Urgent action needed for Newmont Mining investors. Is it worth buying or should you sell? Find out what to do now in the current free analysis from December 6.
Newmont Mining: Buy or sell? Read more here...
