A decision by the Swiss food and beverage giant Nestlé has sparked concerns over its strategic priorities. In a move to defend its profit margins, the company has altered the recipes for its Toffee Crisp and Blue Riband products in the UK market, replacing cocoa with cheaper vegetable fats. The change is so significant that the items can no longer be legally marketed as “chocolate” and must instead be sold with a “chocolate flavour coating” label. This action highlights a tension between maintaining product integrity and managing soaring input costs.
Financial Strain and Strategic Shifts
Nestlé has cited “significant cost increases for cocoa” as the primary driver behind the recipe changes. This comes as the conglomerate faces pressure on multiple fronts. Rising commodity prices for key ingredients like cocoa and coffee, increased marketing expenditures, and the strength of the Swiss franc are all compressing margins. Furthermore, US tariffs of 39% on Swiss imports are adversely impacting its Nespresso business segment.
The company’s recent financial performance reflects these challenges. Nestlé shares are currently trading at 83.35 euros, a level notably below its 50-day moving average. Over the past month, the stock has declined by more than 5%, indicating investor apprehension.
Debt Levels Climb to a Two-Decade Peak
While the rating agency Morningstar DBRS recently confirmed Nestlé’s AA (low) credit rating with a stable outlook, it issued a notable forecast. The agency anticipates that Nestlé’s leverage ratio will reach the 3.0x threshold by the end of 2025, which would mark its highest level in twenty years. This rating is contingent on the expectation that the firm will reduce its debt to between 2.0x and 3.0x by the close of 2028.
Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying Nestle?
To achieve this deleveraging, management has announced a stringent cost-cutting program. Plans include the elimination of approximately 16,000 positions over two years, with around 12,000 of those cuts coming from administrative functions. This restructuring is expected to incur one-time costs of roughly 2 billion euros. Additionally, Nestlé is considering the sale of several assets, potentially including the Blue Bottle Coffee chain, in deals that could total in the mid-single-digit billions.
A Cautious Outlook from the Market
The strategic pivot is occurring under new leadership, with CEO Philipp Navratil having taken the helm in September. He is conducting a comprehensive portfolio review with the goal of achieving cost savings of 3 billion Swiss francs by 2027. Early results show the pressure the company is under: revenue for the first nine months of 2025 contracted by 1.9%, largely due to negative currency translation effects. The reported organic growth of 3.3% was primarily fueled by price increases—a strategy that may face consumer resistance if perceived quality continues to diminish.
Analyst sentiment remains mixed but cautiously optimistic on balance. The average price target for Nestlé shares stands at approximately 88 euros, implying a potential upside of around 13% from current levels. However, recommendations vary. Berenberg advises a “buy” with a 92-euro target, whereas Deutsche Bank and JPMorgan maintain neutral stances.
The core risk for Nestlé is clear: a strategy focused on margin defense through recipe dilution and price hikes may safeguard short-term profits at the expense of long-term brand equity. If consumers perceive a sustained drop in quality, loyalty could erode, prompting a shift to competitors and undermining the very financial metrics the company is striving to protect.
Ad
Nestle Stock: Buy or Sell?! New Nestle Analysis from December 12 delivers the answer:
The latest Nestle figures speak for themselves: Urgent action needed for Nestle investors. Is it worth buying or should you sell? Find out what to do now in the current free analysis from December 12.
Nestle: Buy or sell? Read more here...
