Shares of rare earths producer MP Materials have taken a breather following a spectacular rally that saw them surge more than 240% since the start of the year. The recent pullback of approximately 13% from recent highs coincides with the company securing its fundamental standing through landmark agreements with both Apple and the U.S. Department of Defense. For investors, the central question is whether this consolidation presents a buying opportunity or if the valuation has simply run too far, too fast.
Operational Momentum Meets Strategic Security
The stock’s recent price action, closing yesterday at $53.42, belies a transformative operational period for MP Materials in 2025. The firm has inked three pivotal deals designed to fortify its business model and reduce exposure to volatile market cycles.
A partnership with Saudi Arabia’s state-backed mining giant Maaden establishes a refinery joint venture. Perhaps more significantly, a multi-year supply agreement with Apple, valued at $500 million for high-performance magnets, includes a substantial $200 million upfront payment.
The most groundbreaking development, however, is a strategic partnership with the Pentagon. The U.S. Department of Defense is investing $400 million and, crucially, guaranteeing a price floor of $110 per kilogram for neodymium-praseodymium (NdPr). This pact secures offtake for 100% of the magnet production from MP Materials’ new “10X” facility for an entire decade, granting a rare degree of predictability in the commodities sector.
Record Output and Analyst Approval
This strategic progress is supported by tangible operational results. The company reported its third consecutive quarterly production record in Q3 2025, with NdPr oxide output jumping 51% to 721 metric tons. Management has further guided a return to profitability for the current fourth quarter.
Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying MP Materials?
Institutional analysts are taking note. Morgan Stanley recently upgraded the stock to an “Overweight” rating. Their rationale centers on MP Materials’ strategic importance to U.S. supply chain independence and a favorable market backdrop for rare earth elements. With China still controlling an estimated 90% of global production, the company is viewed as the primary Western counterweight.
Valuation Concerns and Execution Risk
Despite these strengths, valuation remains a key debate. The enormous share price appreciation in 2025 has baked in significant future growth expectations. While bullish analysts see a fair value target as high as $85, more conservative discounted cash flow models suggest a value closer to $16, highlighting a wide disparity.
The primary risk now shifts to execution. The company’s transition from a pure-play miner to an integrated magnet manufacturer is a complex undertaking. The commissioning of its heavy rare earth separation facility is slated for mid-2026, with commercial production at its magnet factory intended to begin by the end of this year. Any delays or quality issues could rapidly erode confidence with its new cornerstone clients, Apple and the Pentagon.
Whether the current consolidation phase concludes favorably will largely depend on MP Materials’ ability to smoothly execute its ambitious 2026 expansion plans and justify its elevated valuation multiples by generating substantial real cash flows.
Ad
MP Materials Stock: Buy or Sell?! New MP Materials Analysis from December 17 delivers the answer:
The latest MP Materials figures speak for themselves: Urgent action needed for MP Materials investors. Is it worth buying or should you sell? Find out what to do now in the current free analysis from December 17.
MP Materials: Buy or sell? Read more here...
