Wall Street enters the new year with a heated debate surrounding Meta Platforms. The company’s core operational performance remains robust, yet investor sentiment is clouded by substantial capital expenditures and lingering skepticism about its artificial intelligence roadmap. The central question for the market is whether the current period of stock weakness represents a buying opportunity or a cautionary tale.
Fundamental Strength Meets Heavy Investment
Meta’s underlying business fundamentals demonstrated clear strength in its third-quarter 2025 report. Quarterly revenue climbed to $51.24 billion, marking a 26% year-over-year increase. Earnings per share came in at $7.25, surpassing analyst expectations of $6.74. Within its advertising segment, the volume of ads delivered grew by 14%, while the average price per ad increased by 10%. Furthermore, the company maintains a solid liquidity position with $44.45 billion in cash, cash equivalents, and short-term securities.
However, this strong performance is juxtaposed against a sharply rising capital requirement. In conjunction with its Q3 results, Meta raised the lower end of its capital expenditure guidance for 2025 to $70 billion. This figure represents a near doubling from the $37.2 billion spent in 2024, intensifying discussions on whether these investments will generate long-term value or suppress near-term returns.
The Analyst Divide: Battleground Status
Market researchers are notably split, reflecting what Baird analyst Colin Sebastian calls a “battleground stock,” where optimistic and skeptical investors are clashing. Sebastian maintains an Outperform rating but slightly reduced his price target from $820 to $815. This pattern of target reductions is widespread: Morgan Stanley cut its target from $820 to $750, Wedbush from $920 to $880, and Cantor Fitzgerald from $830 to $720.
Despite these adjustments, the overall consensus among the 50 analysts covering the stock remains a “Moderate Buy,” with the average price target holding near $821. The stock’s performance, however, tells another story, having underperformed the Nasdaq index by more than 20 percentage points over the past six months—a tangible measure of the “wounded sentiment” Sebastian references.
From a valuation perspective, Meta trades at approximately 10–11 times its expected EV/EBITDA for the next twelve months. This places it slightly below its own historical averages and below competitors like Alphabet, Reddit, and Snap, leading some analysts to view the shares as no longer expensive but also stripped of higher expectations.
The Bull Case: Catalysts on the Horizon
Proponents of the stock, including Baird, point to several concrete potential catalysts centered on AI and monetization:
* The financial forecast for Q1 2026 and the margin outlook, which could serve as a clarifying event.
* The forthcoming next-generation Llama AI model release from the Meta Superintelligence Labs.
* Ongoing feature updates for “Meta AI” across its family of apps.
* Accelerating monetization efforts for WhatsApp and Threads.
* Measurable improvements in ranking, relevance, and user engagement metrics.
* Broader adoption of its Adv+ automation tools within the ad business.
* Additional optionality from wearables and in-house chip development.
The bullish argument suggests that visible progress on these AI initiatives and their revenue contribution in coming quarters could alleviate current market doubts.
Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying Meta?
The Bear Case: Uncertainty and Competitive Pressure
Skeptics focus primarily on the scale of infrastructure spending and competitive threats. Key concerns include:
* The difficult-to-quantify return on investment from massive infrastructure projects.
* Increasingly challenging year-over-year revenue and key performance indicator (KPI) comparisons.
* The relatively slow monetization pace of newer platforms and features targeting younger users.
* The potential resurgence of TikTok as a stronger competitor in the U.S. market.
The sheer magnitude of the capex guidance is a primary weight on the bearish thesis, raising fundamental questions about capital allocation and profit pressure.
Additional Market Dynamics
Other factors are also influencing the stock. On the insider front, SEC filings show that Chief Legal Officer Jennifer Newstead recently sold 519 shares at approximately $664.16 each. Over the preceding 90 days, total insider sales amounted to roughly $25.7 million. While such transactions can have varied personal motivations, some market observers view sustained selling at this level as a cautious signal.
For income-focused investors, Meta paid its quarterly cash dividend of $0.525 per share on December 23, 2025, to shareholders of record on December 15. The dividend program, initiated earlier in the year, is part of the company’s expanded capital return strategy.
Technical and Price Action Perspective
The technical chart picture is mixed. Short-term and long-term moving averages are providing conflicting signals, with the longer-term average hinting at a buy while the shorter-term suggests a sell. Technical analysts also note higher trading volume on down days, which they interpret as a warning sign.
From a recent closing price of €564.50, the shares trade approximately 20% below their 52-week high from February, yet remain nearly 29% above the annual low set in April. This wide range highlights the stock’s recent volatility.
Conclusion: A Conditional Opportunity
Baird concludes that investor focus is likely to shift toward “market-enlarging opportunities” in 2026, but only if Meta can demonstrate tangible successes with its AI and Llama model initiatives. Should that occur, the stock’s currently subdued valuation could become an advantage. Until then, the massive investment cycle and uncertainty surrounding AI’s profit contribution remain the central investment risks.
Ad
Meta Stock: Buy or Sell?! New Meta Analysis from December 24 delivers the answer:
The latest Meta figures speak for themselves: Urgent action needed for Meta investors. Is it worth buying or should you sell? Find out what to do now in the current free analysis from December 24.
Meta: Buy or sell? Read more here...
