A chasm of roughly €500 million has forced the Franco-German armoured vehicle maker KNDS to shelve its planned stock market debut, derailing what was expected to be one of Europe’s largest initial public offerings of the year. The company, which builds Leopard tanks and artillery systems, had aimed to list 20% of its shares in Frankfurt and Paris this summer, but the gap between what owners are demanding and what investors are willing to pay has proved unbridgeable for now.
According to the Financial Times, major institutional buyers signalled a valuation of around €12 billion. Bankers had previously deemed €15 billion realistic, while media speculation months ago had thrown around figures of up to €25 billion. The sticking point lies with the German owner families, who insist on no less than €12.5 billion. That half-billion shortfall has frozen the entire process, postponing any float until at least September, when market conditions might improve.
The delay carries direct consequences for the German government’s parallel plan to take a stake via the state development bank KfW. The purchase price for that stake was always linked to the IPO’s issue price, with a potential premium and earn-out clause. When a valuation of over €18 billion was still in play, the state’s share was calculated at €7.2 billion. That arithmetic has now collapsed. Berlin continues to insist it remains committed to the entry, but the IPO is a prerequisite, and no deal can proceed while the valuation deadlock persists.
The broader defence sector has done the owners no favours. Shares of Czech rival CSG, which staged the largest defence IPO in history in Amsterdam in January, have tumbled 44% below their issue price, wiping more than €11 billion off its market capitalisation. German industry bellwether Rheinmetall has lost 32% of its value so far this year, dropping 19% in a single week after the government cancelled an order for six major warships. That weakness has soured investor sentiment across the sector and made pricing a new issue especially treacherous.
Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying KNDS?
Political recriminations have followed swiftly. The Green party’s budget spokesperson labelled the situation a “disaster for the federal government,” accusing it of pursuing a strategy-less industrial policy and describing the owner families as greedy for snubbing the billions already on the table. The criticism lands particularly hard given the timeline: negotiations between the ministry and the owners dragged into June, and the Bundestag’s budget committee only approved the transaction on 26 June — too late to catch a favourable window. Market observers argue that the government’s hesitation itself is now weighing on the valuation, even though KNDS boasts a fat order book.
Operationally, the company insists the postponement is not a reflection of its health. Morningstar analyst Michael Field sees the core business intact, calling a float in the current downturn counterproductive rather than a sign of weakness. KNDS noted that preparatory work is largely complete and that conversations with investors showed belief in its long-term strategy. Whether a second attempt materialises this year depends on an imminent earnings season turning the tide for beleaguered peers like Rheinmetall and CSG, restoring the investor confidence that has so abruptly vanished.
For now, the IPO window remains firmly shut, and the half-billion euro gap between a seller’s floor and a buyer’s ceiling shows no sign of narrowing. The next opportunity is unlikely to open before the autumn, and only then if the broader defence gloom lifts and Berlin’s political in-fighting subsides.
Ad
KNDS Stock: Buy or Sell?! New KNDS Analysis from July 9 delivers the answer:
The latest KNDS figures speak for themselves: Urgent action needed for KNDS investors. Is it worth buying or should you sell? Find out what to do now in the current free analysis from July 9.
KNDS: Buy or sell? Read more here...
