Etsy is implementing a significant change to one of its core trust mechanisms: the star rating system for its sellers. The online marketplace is shifting from a model that considered only the past year’s reviews to one that incorporates a shop’s entire history. This update, effective March 13, 2026, addresses a key concern raised by long-term vendors and aims to enhance stability across the platform’s ecosystem.
A Shift Towards Long-Term Reputation
Under the previous framework, a shop’s hard-earned reputation could effectively reset to zero after periods of inactivity, as the rating was calculated solely on performance from the preceding twelve months. The revised approach considers all reviews accumulated since a store’s inception. To ensure current service quality remains a prominent factor, Etsy will apply a time-weighting algorithm where the impact of a review halves with each passing year.
This provides sellers with a more consistent reflection of their long-term customer satisfaction. For daily operations, however, the criteria for the “Star Seller” badge remain unchanged. This program will continue to assess performance metrics—such as response times and on-time shipping—from the most recent three-month period.
Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying Etsy?
Investor Focus Amid Market Pressures
This strategic move comes at a challenging time for Etsy, which faces volatile consumer demand. While some institutional investors, including Meridiem Capital Partners, have recently increased their holdings, analysts point to a declining count of active buyers on the platform. Market skepticism is reflected in the share price: closing at €45.53 on Friday, the stock trades approximately 30% below its 52-week high of €65.02.
The true test for Etsy’s growth strategy and Gross Merchandise Sales (GMS) development will arrive in late April. The company is scheduled to release its next quarterly results, likely on April 29. This report will provide concrete data on whether initiatives aimed at seller retention and platform optimization, including the new rating system, are delivering the intended positive momentum.
Ad
Etsy Stock: Buy or Sell?! New Etsy Analysis from March 15 delivers the answer:
The latest Etsy figures speak for themselves: Urgent action needed for Etsy investors. Is it worth buying or should you sell? Find out what to do now in the current free analysis from March 15.
Etsy: Buy or sell? Read more here...
