A stark contrast in sentiment is emerging around MP Materials, the leading U.S. producer of rare earth elements. While Wall Street analysts are issuing bullish upgrades, a significant insider has decided to cash in a portion of his holdings, presenting investors with conflicting messages.
Operational Strength and Strategic Partnerships
Fundamentally, MP Materials is demonstrating robust performance. The company reported a record third quarter, with production of neodymium-praseodymium (NdPr) soaring 51% to 721 metric tons. Revenue reached $53.55 million, surpassing expectations despite a halt in sales to China. Furthermore, the adjusted loss per share was contained at $0.10, a better result than many had anticipated.
The long-term investment case is heavily supported by strategic government alignment. A pivotal $400 million investment from the U.S. Department of Defense (DoD) has made the government MP Materials’ largest shareholder. This partnership establishes an effective price floor for NdPr output, substantially mitigating business risk. Market experts point to this as a cornerstone for building a China-independent supply chain, a critical geopolitical priority.
Adding to this strategic footprint, a joint venture announced in November with the DoD and Saudi Arabian Mining Company (Ma’aden) offers future potential. The collaboration is viewed favorably as it could provide operational flexibility without significant capital expenditure from MP Materials and may secure long-term access to heavy rare earth elements.
Wall Street’s Bullish Consensus
This operational backdrop has fueled a wave of analyst optimism. The latest endorsement came from Morgan Stanley, which upgraded the stock to “Overweight” from an equivalent of “buy” and raised its price target from $68.50 to $71. Analyst Carlos De Alba emphasized the firm’s central role in Western supply chain diversification efforts, arguing that temporary pauses in Chinese export restrictions do not solve the underlying dependency issue.
Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying MP Materials?
The planned commencement of commercial magnet production by the end of 2025—serving electric vehicles, wind turbines, and robotics—is cited as a key future catalyst. Morgan Stanley’s move follows a series of positive ratings from other major institutions, including BMO Capital, JPMorgan, Deutsche Bank, and Goldman Sachs. The collective average price target among analysts currently stands near $79 per share.
Insider Action Tempers Enthusiasm
In a move that contrasts sharply with the external cheer, MP Materials’ own Chairman and CEO, James H. Litinsky, executed a major sale. Regulatory filings with the SEC show he sold 385,000 shares last Friday at prices between $62.79 and $63.42, realizing approximately $24.2 million.
Although Litinsky retains a substantial position of over 13 million shares directly and indirectly, the disposal of nearly 3% of his stake introduced uncertainty. The market reaction was muted but negative, with the equity declining about 1.5% to $61.14 on Monday amid lower-than-average trading volume.
The Path Forward for Investors
For the market, the immediate focus is on execution. The upcoming milestones—specifically the launch of magnet production at the end of 2025 and the operational start of the heavy rare earths separation facility by mid-2026—are viewed as critical for the next phase of growth. The next quarterly report in February 2026 will be a key checkpoint. For now, investors are left to weigh the confident outlook of professional analysts against the profit-taking action of the company’s top executive.
Ad
MP Materials Stock: Buy or Sell?! New MP Materials Analysis from December 10 delivers the answer:
The latest MP Materials figures speak for themselves: Urgent action needed for MP Materials investors. Is it worth buying or should you sell? Find out what to do now in the current free analysis from December 10.
MP Materials: Buy or sell? Read more here...
