Critical Metals shed 6.4% on Tuesday evening as rare-earth equities came under broad pressure, with the selloff tracing back to William Blair’s downgrade of rival USA Rare Earth — a reminder that in this corner of the market, one company’s analyst note can reprice its peers.
The sector-wide retreat was compounded by a second, less intuitive force: speculation that the Trump-Xi meeting could herald a thaw between Washington and Beijing. For rare-earth names, detente reads as a threat rather than a relief, since tighter supply narratives have underpinned the investment case. Critical Metals has now lost 32% over seven sessions, a stretch that puts Tuesday’s decline in the context of a far weaker run rather than a single bad session.
William Blair cut USA Rare Earth from “Outperform” to “Market Perform” on Monday, citing delays in raw-material supply. Critical Metals and MP Materials fell alongside it. The note landed on a competitor, but its substance — the gap between holding a deposit and actually pulling ore from the ground — applies across the pre-production tier of the sector.
Ownership Is Not Output
Critical Metals said on 11 November that it holds 100% of the Tanbreez project, following the completion of its acquisition of European Lithium on 5 November, which made the target a wholly owned subsidiary. That is a clean ownership position. It answers a different question than the one about when mining begins.
The feasibility study for Tanbreez is targeted for Q4 2027. First ore is envisaged for late 2028 to early 2029 — a timetable the company explicitly conditions on permits, financing and construction progress. An intended start date, in other words, is not a secured delivery schedule.
Investors weighing the stock today are therefore also weighing a path whose key operational milestones remain ahead. Keeping project ownership and production prospects as separate items is more useful than folding them into a single promise.
Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying Critical Metals?
Cash on Hand, Capital Structure Alongside
Immediately after the merger, Critical Metals reported roughly US$264.5 million in cash, alongside 194.2 million shares outstanding. Both figures belong to the same balance-sheet picture: the absolute size of the war chest should be read together with the share count, not in isolation.
The company itself lists financing as one of the conditions for its planned start of production. A cash balance is a snapshot; a project timeline describes future steps and their prerequisites. Blurring the two would be as misleading as ignoring the liquidity altogether — or as treating it as proof that construction and first ore will arrive on schedule.
What the Selloff Actually Tests
The practical side of the rare-earth story is where Tuesday’s decline points. At USA Rare Earth, raw-material supply sat at the heart of the analyst call. At Critical Metals, the relevant yardstick is the company’s own announced milestones: the feasibility study, permits, financing and construction progress.
The point is not the daily loss. It is the distinction between a fully held project and mining that is actually under way. For Critical Metals, the road ahead runs through several concrete conditions — and the project story will be judged on how well they are met, with the Trump-Xi meeting and the sector’s reaction over the coming days set to determine how much weight investors give the company’s asset base versus the political weather.
Ad
Critical Metals Stock: Buy or Sell?! New Critical Metals Analysis from November 18 delivers the answer:
The latest Critical Metals figures speak for themselves: Urgent action needed for Critical Metals investors. Is it worth buying or should you sell? Find out what to do now in the current free analysis from November 18.
Critical Metals: Buy or sell? Read more here...
