Commerzbank is trading close enough to its peak that every fresh headline now matters. The shares were last seen at EUR 38.50 in one reading and EUR 38.71 in another, leaving them just 1.74 percent below the July record of EUR 39.18, or 1.20 percent shy of that same high in the Monday move. Over the past year, the stock has gained 15.51 percent, while the twelve-month figure cited separately stands at 16.14 percent. Since the start of the year, it has risen 7.23 percent.
That momentum has not stopped S&P Global Ratings from taking a more cautious view. The agency kept the bank’s issuer rating at A, but cut its outlook from positive to stable. The change reflects integration risks and the possibility that Commerzbank’s standalone capital buffers could disappear if UniCredit were to gain control.
At the heart of the debate is the bank’s CET1 ratio. Under Commerzbank’s own capital return policy, the hard core capital ratio must stay above 13.5 percent after any share buyback if the group is to keep distributing capital while remaining independent. That threshold is now being tested by the takeover story itself. If UniCredit ends up folding Commerzbank into its own structure, the German lender’s capital planning could be absorbed into a wider group framework, which would make the future distribution policy less predictable.
So far, Commerzbank has built a strong record on payouts. It has completed six share buyback programmes since 2023. The latest, worth EUR 524 million, was finished successfully on 9 March 2026. For the 2025 financial year, management has already set out a record capital return of EUR 2.7 billion. Another buyback of up to EUR 540 million is due to begin in February 2026, and the bank still intends to distribute 100 percent of net profit after AT1 coupons in 2026.
The earnings outlook has also been upgraded. Under its “Momentum 2030” strategy, Commerzbank now expects net profit of at least EUR 3.4 billion in 2026, up from a previous target of more than EUR 3.2 billion. Deutsche Bank, meanwhile, reiterated a Buy recommendation in mid-July and said agreed takeovers typically create more shareholder value than hostile ones.
Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying Commerzbank?
Even so, the takeover overhang has not gone away. The acceptance period for UniCredit’s voluntary offer ended in early July, and only a small number of independent shareholders tendered their stock. UniCredit still holds a significant voting stake through derivatives and direct holdings, and market watchers say it is already close to 50 percent of Commerzbank shares, though part of that remains subject to regulatory approval.
Andrea Orcel, UniCredit’s chief executive, told analysts that the fourth quarter of 2026 could be the window for European Central Bank approval, with active control to follow soon after. If that timetable plays out, the key question will be whether Commerzbank’s current 100 percent payout ratio survives the move into a group structure.
Investors will get another checkpoint on Thursday, when the bank releases its second-quarter interim report. The figures will be watched not only for proof that profitability can hold up as interest rates ease, but also for any sign that the bank can still deliver on its capital-return promises. A particular focus will be the net interest income outlook, which the market is already questioning as the ECB moves toward looser policy and the high-rate tailwind fades.
Technically, the shares remain in a strong position. They are 10.73 percent above the 200-day moving average of EUR 34.96, while the 50-day average stands at EUR 37.33. The RSI is 57.9, which leaves room for further upside without the stock being seen as overbought. A decisive break above EUR 39.18 would confirm a fresh advance; another failure there could trigger a double-top pattern and pull the shares back toward EUR 37.33. The annualised volatility of 28.39 percent suggests the next leg could be a lively one.
For now, Commerzbank sits between two narratives: one built on buybacks, higher earnings and a powerful share-price run, the other on integration risk and the possibility that the current capital return machine may not survive unchanged if UniCredit tightens its grip.
Ad
Commerzbank Stock: Buy or Sell?! New Commerzbank Analysis from August 4 delivers the answer:
The latest Commerzbank figures speak for themselves: Urgent action needed for Commerzbank investors. Is it worth buying or should you sell? Find out what to do now in the current free analysis from August 4.
Commerzbank: Buy or sell? Read more here...
