The silver market is experiencing a powerful cyclical upswing, and Coeur Mining finds itself positioned directly in its path. Concurrently, the company’s leadership is advancing a transformative multi-billion dollar acquisition designed to fundamentally reshape its future. For investors, the central question is whether the firm’s dramatic share price appreciation is built on a foundation of sustainable growth.
Valuation and Market Context in a Silver Surge
This dynamic period is being driven by a historic rally in the underlying commodity. On December 17, the spot price for silver reached a new all-time peak of $66.50 per ounce. Primary silver producers like Coeur Mining, whose stock has already surged over 200% in 2025, are key beneficiaries of this powerful tailwind.
The current valuation reflects this boom. Although trading approximately 27% below its 52-week high following the historic rally, the share price remains nearly 140% above its level at the start of the year. Technical indicators, such as a Relative Strength Index (RSI) around 50, suggest high but not extreme short-term momentum.
CEO Mitchell Krebs recently reinforced the company’s strategic direction, centered on the planned all-stock acquisition of New Gold Inc. in a deal valued at $7 billion. This merger aims to create one of North America’s premier precious metals producers by integrating New Gold’s key Canadian assets—the Rainy River and New Afton mines—into Coeur’s existing portfolio.
Core Growth Drivers: Exploration, Synergies, and Margins
Krebs emphasized that growth is already underway, pointing to several concrete catalysts:
Exploration Potential in Mexico: On December 8, Coeur reported significant progress from an aggressive exploration program at its Palmarejo gold-silver complex in Mexico. The company completed approximately 68,000 meters of diamond drilling, marking its largest campaign there since 2012. Notably, about 97% of the 300 km² area remains unexplored, indicating substantial potential for organic resource replacement and reserve expansion.
Financial Synergies from the New Gold Deal: The transaction is structured to leave existing Coeur shareholders with roughly 62% ownership of the combined entity. Projections for 6 anticipate a combined EBITDA of about $3.0 billion and a free cash flow of approximately $2.0 billion. Post-integration, Coeur would benefit from a more diversified asset base, reducing its reliance on any single mining operation.
Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying Coeur Mining?
Operating Leverage from High Silver Prices: The silver price’s ascent into the $66-per-ounce range significantly expands operating margins. Market observers note that Coeur’s substantial leverage to silver could drive record free cash flow in the fourth quarter of 2025. This financial strength supports the strategic shift to concentrate on North American assets.
Risk Assessment and Market Positioning
This expansion is unfolding within a unique market structure. The silver sector is characterized by a structural supply deficit, where industrial demand from AI data centers, photovoltaics, and electric mobility is currently estimated to outstrip available supply—a highly favorable environment for producers like Coeur.
Historically, the stock has been viewed as a volatile play on silver prices. In 2025, its performance has significantly outpaced both the broad GDX mining index and the S&P 500. This very outperformance is now prompting some caution; Cantor Fitzgerald recently downgraded the shares to “Neutral,” signaling that the current valuation may already reflect the substantial gains.
The New Gold acquisition could, however, moderate the typical volatility of a primary silver producer. A more extensive portfolio of mines, metals, and geographic regions should, provided operational integration is successful, lessen dependence on any single silver price scenario.
The Road Ahead: 2026 as a Defining Year
The focus now shifts decisively to the first half of 2026. This period is expected to see the closure of the New Gold acquisition, pending shareholder and regulatory approvals. Simultaneously, market participants are watching to see if silver can sustain its breakout above the $60-per-ounce threshold, a level critical to many financial models.
Operationally, the upcoming Q4 2025 earnings report takes center stage. The market awaits confirmation that Coeur, on a standalone basis prior to the merger, can achieve an annualized EBITDA run-rate exceeding $1 billion. Success on this front, coupled with silver prices remaining near record levels, would establish a solid foundation for the next phase of the company’s transformation.
Ad
Coeur Mining Stock: Buy or Sell?! New Coeur Mining Analysis from December 18 delivers the answer:
The latest Coeur Mining figures speak for themselves: Urgent action needed for Coeur Mining investors. Is it worth buying or should you sell? Find out what to do now in the current free analysis from December 18.
Coeur Mining: Buy or sell? Read more here...
