A critical component of Coca-Cola’s strategic portfolio review has encountered a significant hurdle. The beverage giant’s planned sale of its Costa Coffee chain is in jeopardy as negotiations with the preferred bidder, private equity firm TDR Capital, have stalled over price disagreements. This last-minute impasse, emerging just before the week’s trading began, prompts investors to reassess the deal’s importance to the overall Coca-Cola investment thesis.
Stalled Negotiations and Strategic Alternatives
According to weekend reports from the Financial Times and Reuters, Coca-Cola entered into last-ditch discussions with TDR Capital on December 13-14 in an effort to salvage the transaction. TDR Capital, which controls assets like the UK supermarket chain Asda, had only recently been selected as the favored bidder. The talks are now frozen due to a gap in valuation expectations.
The current proposed deal structure involves a partial sale. TDR Capital would assume operational control of Costa, while Coca-Cola would retain a minority stake. This arrangement is designed to allow the corporation to maintain exposure to the coffee market without the burden of direct management. Coca-Cola’s original acquisition of Costa from Whitbread in 2018 carried an enterprise value of $5.1 billion. No specific figures from the current valuation dispute have been disclosed.
Should an agreement prove unreachable, Coca-Cola faces two primary paths forward: retaining Costa within its corporate structure—a move the market could interpret as a setback for its capital allocation strategy—or restarting the sale process with other interested parties.
Analyst Confidence Remains Unshaken
Despite the uncertainty surrounding Costa, analyst sentiment toward Coca-Cola shares remains decidedly positive. Robert Ottenstein of Evercore ISI reaffirmed his “Buy” rating and $82 price target for the stock just as news of the difficult negotiations broke. This target sits substantially above the stock’s closing price in US trading on Friday.
The broader analyst consensus echoes this optimism. On average, the stock carries a “Strong Buy” recommendation with a mean price target of $79.38. The rationale centers on Coca-Cola’s core, globally scaled beverage segments, which are viewed as stable and highly profitable irrespective of the Costa outcome. This perspective is bolstered by the company’s total one-year return of approximately 15% and its esteemed status as a “Dividend King,” having raised its dividend for over 60 consecutive years.
Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying Coca-Cola?
For context, the share price closed at €60.11 in German trading on Friday, trading roughly 13% below its 52-week high. This level suggests a period of consolidation rather than a crisis of investor confidence.
Key Facts at a Glance
- The sale of Costa Coffee to TDR Capital is stalled over valuation disagreements.
- Coca-Cola originally purchased Costa in 2018 for $5.1 billion.
- The planned deal is a majority sale, with Coca-Cola keeping a minority interest.
- The analyst consensus is a “Strong Buy” with an average $79.38 price target.
- The stock has delivered a total return (including dividends) of around 15% over the past twelve months.
Leadership Transition Adds Strategic Dimension
The potential Costa divestiture coincides with a major leadership transition at the company. It was confirmed earlier in the week that Henrique Braun will succeed long-time CEO James Quincey in the first quarter of 2026, with Quincey moving to the role of Executive Chairman.
Viewed through this lens, the Costa deal represents a strategic streamlining ahead of the handover. A successful sale would signal a more focused portfolio, reduced operational complexity in the lower-margin coffee retail business, and increased financial flexibility for the incoming leadership. It would be seen as evidence of Coca-Cola’s commitment to allocating capital toward its higher-margin core brands and categories.
Market Implications for the Week Ahead
The immediate focus is on the outcome of the weekend negotiations. A successful agreement with TDR Capital would be interpreted as a sign of disciplined portfolio optimization. Market observers suggest freed-up capital would likely be directed toward share buybacks or debt reduction—actions typically welcomed by investors.
Conversely, a collapse in talks would thrust questions about Costa’s valuation and strategic worth into the spotlight. An abrupt end to negotiations could place short-term downward pressure on the share price as the market re-evaluates the coffee unit’s profitability. Consequently, communications from management on Monday morning will be crucial. A clear explanation of Coca-Cola’s intended path forward for Costa, whether the sale proceeds or not, will be key for determining the stock’s near-term direction.
Ad
Coca-Cola Stock: Buy or Sell?! New Coca-Cola Analysis from December 14 delivers the answer:
The latest Coca-Cola figures speak for themselves: Urgent action needed for Coca-Cola investors. Is it worth buying or should you sell? Find out what to do now in the current free analysis from December 14.
Coca-Cola: Buy or sell? Read more here...
