The Chinese electric vehicle titan BYD confronts a critical juncture as operational challenges intensify. While the company continues its aggressive global expansion, significant quality control issues are emerging as a substantial threat. A new large-scale vehicle recall has dampened market sentiment, prompting a fundamental question among stakeholders: is this a temporary setback on BYD’s growth trajectory, or does it signal a deeper erosion of confidence in its manufacturing integrity?
A Disturbing Pattern of Recalls Emerges
Chinese market regulators issued a directive this week, compelling BYD to recall 88,981 units of its Qin PLUS DM-i model. This action affects vehicles manufactured between January 2021 and September 2023.
The recall stems from inconsistencies identified in the battery pack production process. For drivers, the potential consequence is severe: in worst-case scenarios, vehicles could completely lose their ability to operate in all-electric mode. Compounding the reputational damage for BYD is the fact that this recall was initiated following a defect investigation by the regulatory authority itself, not a voluntary action by the company.
This incident is not an isolated event but part of a troubling trend observed throughout the year:
Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying BYD?
- Mid-October 2024: Over 115,000 units from the Tang and Yuan Pro model lines were recalled due to design flaws.
- September 2024: Nearly 97,000 vehicles required service to address defective steering control units.
- Cumulative 2024 Recalls: The total number of vehicles recalled this year now exceeds 210,000.
Financial Performance and Valuation Under Pressure
These operational headaches coincide with a strained financial performance. A brutal price war in BYD’s domestic market is taking a clear toll. October sales figures came in 12 percent lower than the previous year, while third-quarter profit witnessed a sharp 33 percent contraction, placing significant pressure on the company’s profit margins.
The stock’s performance reflects deep investor uncertainty. Although the shares have declined approximately 7 percent over the past month, they managed a surprising weekly rebound of 5.1 percent. This volatility leaves market participants questioning whether the current share price represents a value opportunity or a value trap.
From a valuation perspective, BYD shares are currently trading at a price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of 21.1x. This places the stock above a calculated fair value of 17.3x, suggesting it carries a premium relative to its current fundamental qualities. In contrast, more optimistic Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) models, which anticipate a substantial improvement in free cash flow by 2035, project the stock could be undervalued by nearly 13 percent.
This valuation discrepancy highlights the core challenge for BYD. To maintain its competitive edge as a vertically integrated battery and vehicle manufacturer, the company must urgently address these recurring manufacturing deficiencies. If these systemic quality issues persist, they threaten to undermine the compelling long-term growth narrative that investors are banking on.
Ad
BYD Stock: Buy or Sell?! New BYD Analysis from November 29 delivers the answer:
The latest BYD figures speak for themselves: Urgent action needed for BYD investors. Is it worth buying or should you sell? Find out what to do now in the current free analysis from November 29.
BYD: Buy or sell? Read more here...
