Austria’s Supreme Court (OGH) has ruled that a fall at home during working hours does not automatically qualify as a workplace accident. What matters for coverage under the statutory accident insurance scheme in home office is whether the specific activity that triggered the accident has a sufficiently close causal link to the insured employment.
At the centre of the case was an administrative clerk who was working in her home office during regular hours. She went down to the cellar of her
A private need breaks the insurance cover
Both the accident insurer and the OGH declined to classify the incident as a workplace accident. The claim for a disability pension was dismissed. In the judges’ view, fetching the mint syrup served a purely private need of the employee.
Statutory accident insurance protection does in principle extend to activities outside the company premises, including in the home office. That protection, however, does not stretch to every action within a private residence. Where the substantive connection to the actual work activity is missing and an economic self-interest dominates instead, the safety net of accident insurance falls away.
Drawing the line on commuting cases
Distinguishing work-related routes from private errands has occupied courts for decades. Germany’s Federal Social Court (BSG), for instance, ruled on 27 October 1976 that walking to a detached private garage was insured (case no. 2 RU 247/74), because the direct link to starting the commute was paramount.
The current OGH decision makes clear that home office workers who interrupt their work to handle everyday household or supply errands must look closely at how those movements are classified in law.
Routes that serve exclusively to satisfy personal preferences or needs — such as going down to the cellar for a refreshment — remain, under settled case law, part of the employee’s private sphere of risk.
