Mercedes-Benz shares climbed 3.9% to €42.05 on Thursday, but the advance owes little to anything the Stuttgart carmaker said about itself. The lift came from Continental, whose strong quarterly figures and upgraded profitability guidance — reported in the media — galvanised European auto stocks across the board. For anyone reading the move as a verdict on Mercedes-Benz, that distinction matters: a brighter sector mood can support a share price without altering a single line of the company’s published results or the analysts’ view of them.
What the third quarter actually delivered
The company’s own numbers landed on 28 October, covering the third quarter of 2026. Revenue came in at €30.7 billion, with EBIT of €1.77 billion and net profit of €1.52 billion. Those figures document how the business performed; the Continental news explains why the stock found favour. Conflating the two would be a mistake — a one-day gain is no evidence that Mercedes-Benz’s underlying business has improved.
Two banks, two directions, one cautious tone
Analyst reaction has been mixed but uniformly restrained on valuation. UBS cut its price target to €42.50 from €45.00 on 29 October while keeping a “Neutral” rating. DZ Bank followed on Friday, lowering its fair value to €48 from €55 but sticking with “Buy.” Analyst Michael Punzet tied that adjustment to persistent weakness in China and the profit warning issued roughly a week earlier, even as he acknowledged the quarterly figures had slightly beaten expectations. The combination is awkward: a better-than-forecast quarter on its own does not establish a durable recovery story.
Free cash flow is where the argument will be settled
The metric that best captures the doubt is free cash flow from the industrial business, which amounted to just €172 million in the third quarter of 2026. For the full year, Mercedes-Benz now expects a figure well below the prior year’s level following that earlier guidance cut. This is the number that answers whether the operating business is once again generating dependable funds — and a single improved earnings line would not dispel the uncertainty on its own. Investors should separate positive surprises measured against lowered expectations from a genuine operational turnaround.
At Mercedes-Benz Cars, the expected adjusted return on sales for 2026 now sits at 2% to 3%, down from 3% to 5% before the revision. That narrower band is the operating yardstick against which progress will be judged. Should the carmaker achieve stability within it and lift industrial cash generation, the constructive case would gain traction — and DZ Bank’s retained Buy rating shows that a more conservative earnings assumption and a positive stance can coexist.
Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying Mercedes-Benz?
The risks cutting the other way
Mercedes-Benz attributed the guidance cut to an increasingly difficult market in China and higher costs in the fourth quarter, including elevated material expenses. Market-side and cost-side pressures are therefore arriving together, and stabilisation in one area could prove insufficient if the other deteriorates further. The danger for shareholders is not merely a weak result — it is an earnings gain unaccompanied by a correspondingly stronger cash flow, which would leave doubts about the financial trajectory firmly in place. In the worst case, investors would not simply wait longer for a recovery; they would have to ask whether the reduced valuation offers a sound enough foundation. DZ Bank’s lower target deserves as much weight as its continued endorsement.
Personnel plans and the February checkpoint
Alongside the figures, CEO Ola Källenius told the results presentation that Mercedes-Benz would restart its voluntary severance programme for indirect functions in Germany in December, according to media reports. That is a concrete next step rather than a completed reduction in headcount.
The next substantive reference point is the annual results in February, with China and investment spending flagged by analysts as likely focal points — an expectation, not a confirmed company announcement. Punzet’s cut to €42.50 from €45.00, paired with his neutral rating, underscores that the strategic response may matter as much for valuation as the coming set of numbers. So long as the lowered expectations hold, stabilisation remains a plausible scenario; add improving industrial cash flow and the recovery case would acquire real substance. Let China weakness or cost pressures intensify, and that case comes under fresh strain. What counts for the investment decision, then, is not a single attractive valuation but the combination of resilient results, stronger cash generation and a convincing strategic answer.
Ad
Mercedes-Benz Stock: Buy or Sell?! New Mercedes-Benz Analysis from November 4 delivers the answer:
The latest Mercedes-Benz figures speak for themselves: Urgent action needed for Mercedes-Benz investors. Is it worth buying or should you sell? Find out what to do now in the current free analysis from November 4.
Mercedes-Benz: Buy or sell? Read more here...
