Vonovia is being pulled in several directions at once: higher-for-longer financing costs, renewed political pressure in Berlin and a more cautious outlook for growth across Europe’s property sector. The shares ended yesterday’s Xetra session at 16.65 euro, leaving the DAX-listed landlord 32 percent down since the start of the year and only 2.9 percent above the 52-week low of 16.18 euro marked on 8 October.
Jefferies added to the pressure by cutting its price target for Vonovia to 23.00 euro from 28.50 euro yesterday, while keeping its buy recommendation in place. The move still implies upside from the current level, but it also reflects a less optimistic view of the sector’s near-term drivers. According to Jefferies analyst Pierre-Emmanuel Clouard, refinancing risk after existing rate locks expire is no longer the biggest burden on European real estate values. Even so, funding remains expensive, and the broker lowered its average price targets for European property names.
The deeper concern now, Jefferies argues, is that other operating headwinds are taking over. Those include weaker external growth, slower dividend increases and the prospect of renewed pressure on portfolio valuations. The sector is also facing further consolidation.
Berlin remains a particularly sensitive part of the story. A planned meeting between Vonovia chief executive Luka Mucic and Left Party politician Luigi Pantisano collapsed after a dispute over the circumstances. Vonovia said the journalist in question had merely been copied on correspondence, while Die Linke described the episode as stalling tactics.
The political stakes are high. In September’s Berlin state election, Die Linke won 25.7 percent of the vote in the preliminary result. Elif Eralp has said she wants to make expropriation of large housing companies, with compensation, part of any possible coalition talks. Media reports say such demands could affect more than 200,000 apartments in the capital.
Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying Vonovia?
Operationally, the company is responding with restraint. Luka Mucic is scaling back new-build activity in Berlin to limit risk, and the group is broadening its focus while adjusting investment plans to the tougher environment.
The pressure is not only political. Vonovia has also faced legal setbacks around rent increases at various locations. Dresden’s district court rejected the company’s lawsuit against a tenant, making a planned rise in monthly rent from 669 to 705 euro moot. In Leipzig and Berlin-Tegel, the landlord also ran into formal obstacles tied to heating-cost statements and surcharges for access to local transport.
SPD lead candidate Steffen Krach continues to reject expropriation plans, but for investors the immediate question is whether enough of the political and operational risk is already reflected in the stock. For now, the market is answering with caution.
Ad
Vonovia Stock: Buy or Sell?! New Vonovia Analysis from October 15 delivers the answer:
The latest Vonovia figures speak for themselves: Urgent action needed for Vonovia investors. Is it worth buying or should you sell? Find out what to do now in the current free analysis from October 15.
Vonovia: Buy or sell? Read more here...
