The arithmetic at Rheinmetall is becoming uncomfortable. Second-quarter sales jumped 69 to 70 percent to €3.289 billion, operating profit surged 115 percent to €562 million, and the order book stands at a record €80 to €80.5 billion. Yet the shares closed Friday at €1,036.00, down 3.2 percent on the day and nursing losses that have accumulated for weeks. The gap between what the Düsseldorf-based defense group is delivering and how the market is pricing it has rarely felt wider.
A Contract That Isn’t Coming — Yet
The immediate trigger for Friday’s slide was a dawning realization about the company’s anticipated collaboration with Boeing Australia. What had been expected as an initial order worth nearly €1 billion now appears unlikely to materialize in the near term. Germany’s armed forces, the Bundeswehr, are reportedly holding off on a decision, preferring instead to weigh competing proposals from rivals Helsing and Airbus before committing.
That matters because the Boeing Australia work was viewed as a cornerstone of Rheinmetall’s ambitions in the drone and aviation segment — a growth area the company has been eager to expand. The disappointment lands at a delicate moment for the broader European defense complex, with shares of RENK, Hensoldt and TKMS all coming under pressure in recent sessions.
Adding to the uncertainty is the creeping timeline on “Arminius,” the project to procure the Boxer wheeled armored vehicle. The first tranche, valued at €12.4 billion for Rheinmetall, is now slated for ordering only at year-end. Chief Executive Armin Papperger has said final negotiations are set for the second week of September, with parliamentary handling scheduled for December 9 and signing to follow within five to ten days. Each postponement chips away at investor confidence in the reliability of the Bundeswehr’s procurement calendar — a risk the market is now actively pricing.
The CEO in the Crosshairs
Papperger himself has become part of the story. Media reports have trained attention on halted flagship projects, delivery delays and a leadership structure that critics describe as heavily centered on one person. The scrutiny comes alongside a notable bearish position: hedge fund Capital Fund Management has built a net short position of 0.90 percent of Rheinmetall’s shares, according to disclosure data — a bet by professional investors that the stock has further to fall.
The backdrop includes the loss of the F126 frigate program, which knocked roughly €300 million out of the company’s planning and contributed to a lowered full-year sales forecast of €13.7 billion to €14.2 billion. That guidance revision, announced on August 6, remains a live factor in the stock’s de-rating. Even the revised target still implies organic growth of 28 to 31 percent, but the market’s focus has shifted from the trajectory to the execution risk.
JPMorgan analyst David Perry captured the shift in sentiment when he downgraded the stock from “Overweight” to “Neutral” on May 7, cutting his price target to €1,500. His reasoning: while the second-quarter numbers were strong, medium-term uncertainties had grown, with updated projections for order intake and capital expenditure pointing to lower revenues between 2027 and 2030.
Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying Rheinmetall?
Operational Progress That Isn’t Moving the Needle
None of this is to suggest the company is standing still. American Rheinmetall has delivered the first of eight prototypes of the Lynx XM30 infantry fighting vehicle to the US Army. Germany’s federal aviation office has granted provisional airworthiness certification to the LUNA NG unmanned reconnaissance system. A smaller but symbolically useful contract has arrived from the US: Rheinmetall Canada will supply the US Navy, via the Canadian Commercial Corporation, with replacement components for MSU-200NAV mobile launchers — a deal in the single-digit millions of euros, with deliveries scheduled between end-2026 and end-2028.
The Bundeswehr remains a steady source of smaller-scale work as well. In July, Rheinmetall booked an order worth more than €500 million for mobile rescue stations, pushing the total to 165 systems with a gross value exceeding €600 million.
Insider Buying as a Counter-Signal
Perhaps the most intriguing counterpoint to the bearish narrative is Papperger’s own behavior. Through his holding vehicle ATP Holding, the CEO purchased shares in three tranches in June totaling roughly €12 million, the most recent on June 25 at an average price of €954.62 — close to the stock’s current 52-week low of €902.50.
Those purchases predate the current debate over his leadership, which complicates any reading of them as a direct response to the recent criticism. But they do signal confidence in the company’s strategic direction from the person best positioned to know what’s coming. Whether that conviction will be enough to offset doubts about the delivery of Rheinmetall’s ambitious growth plans — the company has targeted a fivefold increase in revenue to around €50 billion by 2030 at an operating margin above 20 percent, ambitions floated at last November’s Capital Markets Day — remains an open question.
For now, investors are left weighing a book-to-bill ratio above three, a backlog where 70 percent counts as firm orders, and a 44 percent jump in order intake against a leadership question that won’t go away. The September Arminius negotiations and any movement on the Boeing Australia front will likely determine which way the scales tip.
Ad
Rheinmetall Stock: Buy or Sell?! New Rheinmetall Analysis from September 5 delivers the answer:
The latest Rheinmetall figures speak for themselves: Urgent action needed for Rheinmetall investors. Is it worth buying or should you sell? Find out what to do now in the current free analysis from September 5.
Rheinmetall: Buy or sell? Read more here...
