The price of gold is notoriously fickle, capable of shifting direction in a single trading session. For mining equities like Newmont, these moves are often amplified. This dynamic was on full display recently, as a pullback in the bullion price coincided with the company’s ex-dividend date, creating a perfect storm of downward pressure. The episode has highlighted a stark divide in Wall Street’s outlook for the world’s leading gold producer.
A Convergence of Negative Catalysts
The primary driver behind the share price decline was a sharp retreat in the spot price of gold. After benefiting from geopolitical tensions, sentiment toward the precious metal reversed abruptly. Silver also came under significant pressure, weighing on the broader mining sector.
A technical factor exacerbated the move. March 3rd marked the ex-dividend date for Newmont’s quarterly distribution of $0.26 per share. On such dates, a stock’s price is typically adjusted downward by the dividend amount, which can intensify selling activity.
The broader market environment contributed to the “risk-off” mood. Concerns over hotter-than-expected producer price data and persistent geopolitical uncertainty reduced investors’ appetite for risk, a climate that often negatively impacts both gold and gold miners simultaneously.
Wall Street’s Divided House
Despite the sell-off, many analysts maintain a constructive long-term view, though their opinions and price targets vary widely. Citigroup raised its target substantially from $118 to $150, reiterating a “Buy” rating. Sanford C. Bernstein was even more bullish, upgrading the stock from “Market Perform” to “Outperform” and lifting its target from $121 to $157.
Bernstein’s upgrade was rooted in a significantly more optimistic long-term gold price forecast. The analysts revised their projections to $4,800 per ounce for 2026 and $6,100 for 2030. This new valuation framework places greater emphasis on central bank and ETF demand dynamics, as well as the potential impact of U.S. interest rate cuts. Based on these assumptions, Bernstein increased its 2026 EBITDA estimate for Newmont by 26% to $21.9 billion, arguing the stock offers clear leverage to rising gold prices.
However, not all revisions were positive. TD Securities lowered its target from $120 to $118, maintaining a “Hold” rating. The Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce cut its target more sharply, from $71 to $67.
Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying Newmont Mining?
Record Cash Flow Meets Operational Challenges
The recent share price weakness contrasts with the company’s strong recent financial performance. Newmont reported a record annual free cash flow of $7.3 billion for 2025, including $2.8 billion generated in the fourth quarter alone. This robust cash generation enabled a debt reduction of $3.4 billion, leaving the company in a net cash position by year-end.
Operational and earnings results were also solid. Fourth-quarter earnings per share came in at $2.52, comfortably surpassing the market consensus of $1.81. Revenue also exceeded forecasts, reaching $6.82 billion against expectations of $6.18 billion.
Looking ahead, Newmont is guiding for a deliberately lower gold production profile in 2026—approximately 5.26 million ounces, or about 10% less than 2025—along with higher all-in sustaining costs. Costs are projected to be $1,680 per ounce, up from $1,358. This is due to mine sequencing and lower grades. An operational setback is also a factor: bushfires in December 2025 damaged critical water infrastructure at the Boddington mine in Australia, which is expected to create a production shortfall of roughly 60,000 ounces in Q1 2026.
Concurrently, the company is signaling its growth ambitions. It has committed to an $800 million investment over six years to expand the Cerro Negro mine in Argentina.
Joint Venture Dispute Escalates
Adding to the complexity is an escalating conflict with Barrick Gold over the Nevada Gold Mines joint venture. Newmont disclosed it has sent Barrick a default notice, alleging mismanagement. The claims include the alleged diversion of joint venture funds to develop Barrick’s separate Fourmile project. Newmont emphasized that transactions related to joint ventures must respect the protective mechanisms of the governing agreements. The core issue, according to Newmont, revolves around the operation and management of Nevada Gold Mines, where performance and asset value have suffered over the past six years.
The market impact of these combined factors was clear: over a seven-day period, Newmont’s shares declined by 3.04%.
Investor attention will now turn to the first-quarter 2026 results, due on April 23, 2026. Updates on the recovery efforts at Boddington, the expansion in Argentina, and the evolving Nevada joint venture dispute will be in sharp focus.
Ad
Newmont Mining Stock: Buy or Sell?! New Newmont Mining Analysis from March 5 delivers the answer:
The latest Newmont Mining figures speak for themselves: Urgent action needed for Newmont Mining investors. Is it worth buying or should you sell? Find out what to do now in the current free analysis from March 5.
Newmont Mining: Buy or sell? Read more here...
