PayPal Holdings, Inc. is navigating a challenging period as its stock price spirals toward annual lows. Trading closed at $56.74 on Thursday, hovering just above its 52-week low. The central debate among investors has shifted from whether key price support will hold to a question of its durability.
Regulatory Uncertainty and a Rakuten Dispute Add Pressure
Beyond analyst sentiment, two specific issues are weighing on the fintech giant. First, a conflict has emerged with Rakuten Advertising, which removed PayPal’s Honey browser extension from its affiliate network. Rakuten alleges that code within Honey disrupted its platform’s functionality. PayPal has countered these claims, stating the problematic code originated prior to its acquisition of Honey, impacted less than 0.1% of traffic, and has since been disabled. Nevertheless, the removal deals a blow to a meaningful affiliate revenue stream during a time of broader market valuation concerns.
Simultaneously, proposed regulatory changes cast a shadow. Former President Donald Trump’s suggested 10% interest rate cap on credit cards has introduced sector-wide nervousness, despite remaining only a proposal. Analysts at Mizuho offer a contrasting view, suggesting such credit constraints could benefit Buy-Now-Pay-Later (BNPL) providers like PayPal. They project BNPL volume exceeding $40 billion for 2025, though this potential upside has yet to counteract the prevailing negative momentum.
A Loss of Analyst Confidence
The stock’s decline coincides with a wave of downgrades from major investment banks. TD Cowen delivered the most severe adjustment, slashing its price target from $80 to $65—a nearly 19% reduction. Piper Sandler modestly lowered its target from $76 to $74 while maintaining a neutral rating. Compass Point remains notably pessimistic, reiterating a sell rating with a $55 target.
The rationale behind these moves centers on cautious near-term guidance, regulatory overhangs, and doubts about growth sustainability. This skepticism persists even though PayPal’s Q3 2025 earnings per share of $1.34 surpassed the $1.20 consensus estimate. The market’s deep-seated distrust is reflected in a forward P/E ratio of just 11.4.
Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying PayPal?
Glimmers of Hope Contrast with Insider Sales
Amid the gloom, several potential catalysts are on the horizon. Interactive Brokers is set to begin supporting PayPal’s PYUSD stablecoin next week. Furthermore, OpenAI has announced plans to integrate PayPal into ChatGPT by 2026 for “Agentic Commerce,” positioning the company as a potential beneficiary of AI-driven trade.
However, these long-term prospects are overshadowed by recent insider selling activity. During the prior quarter, corporate insiders disposed of millions of dollars worth of stock, including over 9,000 shares sold by Executive Vice President Aaron Webster. While such transactions are often routine, they rarely convey bullish confidence to the market.
The Technical and Fundamental Crossroads
All eyes are now fixed on the critical technical level of $55.85—the stock’s 52-week low. A decisive break below this support could trigger automated selling and intensify downward pressure.
The divergence between current price and analyst consensus is stark. The average price target among 26 covering analysts stands at $77.42, implying over 35% upside from current levels. For this optimism to materialize, PayPal must first demonstrate that it can stabilize and defend its current precarious footing. The immediate future hinges on this battle between deteriorating sentiment and the company’s underlying fundamentals.
Ad
PayPal Stock: Buy or Sell?! New PayPal Analysis from January 16 delivers the answer:
The latest PayPal figures speak for themselves: Urgent action needed for PayPal investors. Is it worth buying or should you sell? Find out what to do now in the current free analysis from January 16.
PayPal: Buy or sell? Read more here...
