Shares of Lynas Rare Earths Ltd. are receiving a significant structural boost this week, driven by a triple promotion within major global indices. This comes as the company navigates recent operational challenges, with market experts divided on its near-term trajectory against a backdrop of stabilizing geopolitical support for the sector.
Index-Driven Demand and Analyst Perspectives
The primary catalyst is Lynas’s simultaneous addition to three S&P benchmark indices as of Monday: the S&P/ASX 50, the S&P Global 1200, and the S&P International 700. This triple inclusion compels index-tracking and passively managed funds to adjust their holdings, creating a predictable wave of institutional buying interest.
Analyst coverage presents a mixed picture. On December 21, CLSA reaffirmed its “Buy” recommendation, setting a price target of AUD 21.20. From current levels, this implies an upside potential of nearly 70%, suggesting the firm views the stock as substantially undervalued. In contrast, Jefferies has maintained a more cautious “Hold” stance since early December, with a target of AUD 14.50. Their focus rests on the pace of any short-term recovery in rare earths pricing.
Trading volume has recently exceeded the monthly average of 11.6 million shares, indicating heightened institutional activity that has provided support above the AUD 12.50 level.
Operational Setback and Recovery Focus
Despite the index-related tailwind, Lynas is managing the aftermath of a production disruption. On November 24, the company reported a significant power supply failure at its Kalgoorlie Rare Earths Processing Facility.
The incident resulted in an estimated one-month loss of production for Mixed Rare Earth Carbonate (MREC), which is expected to pressure fourth-quarter revenue figures. Investors are now closely monitoring the restart timeline and whether the plant can return to its full operational capacity promptly. A mitigating factor is that customer shipments have largely been maintained using existing inventory, limiting immediate negative impact on the share price.
Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying Lynas?
Geopolitical Winds Shift to Support
A key supportive factor emerged from the geopolitical arena. Trade tensions and tariff concerns that weighed on the sector earlier in the year have eased considerably. The catalyst was the October 30 meeting between Donald Trump and Xi Jinping, which resulted in a truce in the trade dispute.
This October shift proved more consequential for current conditions than more recent headlines. Since then, rare earths prices have stabilized. While the previous scarcity premium for non-Chinese suppliers has normalized, political backing has not wavered. A follow-on agreement among Western nations in November, sometimes referred to as the “Trump-Labor Pact,” earmarks approximately USD 2 billion to build and secure supply chains outside China. This policy move has effectively established a valuation floor for the sector, from which Lynas benefits.
Valuation Premium and Technical Position
The market continues to award Lynas a valuation premium compared to the broader materials sector. This is due to its unique position as the only significant producer of separated heavy rare earths outside China. Combined with its long-term contracts, including with defense industry customers, this strategic role has driven the stock’s outperformance against the ASX 200 Materials Index over the past three months.
From a chart perspective, the equity is currently consolidating in a relatively tight range around AUD 12.40 to AUD 12.60. Over the last 30 days, the share price has retreated, now sitting roughly 45% below its 52-week high of EUR 13.15. However, it remains well above its annual low and shows a year-to-date gain exceeding 80%. A Relative Strength Index (RSI) reading near 37 indicates recent selling pressure without yet reaching deeply oversold territory.
The Path Forward: Q1 2026 in Focus
Attention is now turning to the first quarter of 2026. The crucial next data point will be the quarterly report due in late January, where Lynas is expected to provide concrete updates on the Kalgoorlie facility’s status and the production recovery pathway. A convincing demonstration of fully restored capacity would bolster the bullish case outlined by CLSA. Conversely, any lack of confirmation or signs of persistent operational constraints would likely validate Jefferies’s more conservative assessment, potentially pulling the stock back toward more defensive valuation levels.
Ad
Lynas Stock: Buy or Sell?! New Lynas Analysis from December 23 delivers the answer:
The latest Lynas figures speak for themselves: Urgent action needed for Lynas investors. Is it worth buying or should you sell? Find out what to do now in the current free analysis from December 23.
Lynas: Buy or sell? Read more here...
