PayPal finds itself navigating a complex transition. While immediate market focus centers on decelerating growth in its core operations, the company’s leadership is simultaneously executing a profound strategic overhaul. This overhaul includes a significant move: applying for its own industrial bank charter. It is this very contrast between near-term pressures and long-term ambition that currently defines the investment debate surrounding the fintech giant.
The Drive for “PayPal Bank”: A Long-Term Gambit
In a clear signal of its future direction, PayPal submitted applications to the U.S. Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) and Utah’s Department of Financial Institutions on December 15. The goal is to establish “PayPal Bank” as an industrial bank licensed in Utah.
Approval of this charter would fundamentally alter PayPal’s capabilities, allowing it to:
- Offer FDIC-insured deposits directly to customers.
- Provide loans directly to small businesses without an intermediary.
- Reduce reliance on partner banks significantly, bringing more of the financial value chain in-house.
The company is already a player in business lending, having extended over $30 billion in working capital since its programs launched. An in-house bank license could improve margins in this segment and deepen relationships with its approximately 35 million merchant accounts. Market observers view this as a move toward a vertically integrated model, a path already taken by competitors like Block (Square).
Near-Term Headwinds: Analyst Adjustments and Sector Pressure
This long-term vision unfolds against a backdrop of present-day challenges. Mizuho Securities recently became a voice of near-term caution, lowering its price target for PayPal shares from $84 to $75, though it maintained an “Outperform” rating. The adjustment followed more guarded commentary from management regarding fourth-quarter performance.
Analysts are particularly focused on the branded checkout business—the ubiquitous PayPal button in online stores. The company’s CFO suggested in early December that growth here would be “at least a few percentage points slower” in Q4 than it was in Q3. In response, Mizuho revised its growth forecast for branded checkout down to approximately 1% for the quarter, from a prior estimate of 4%.
Expectations for “Pay with Venmo” were also tempered slightly, with growth projections adjusted from 45% year-over-year to around 40%. While still robust, this indicates that even PayPal’s key growth engines are not entirely immune to broader pressures.
Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying PayPal?
Mizuho noted that the stock’s valuation remains appealing, citing a price-to-earnings ratio of roughly 11.9 and a Piotroski Score of 9 as evidence of a solid financial foundation, despite the top-line slowdown.
The current investor skepticism aligns with a difficult period for the fintech sector. Although PayPal’s Q3 earnings of $1.34 per share handily beat expectations of $1.19, the market is concentrating on structural issues. A primary concern is the transaction margin, which is under pressure as lower-margin, unbranded payment volumes (like white-label solutions) grow faster than branded volumes.
Competitive intensity is also rising:
– Apple Pay is gaining ground at the digital checkout.
– Buy-Now, Pay-Later (BNPL) providers are challenging PayPal’s installment loan offerings.
Mizuho is not alone in its cautious stance. Morgan Stanley recently downgraded the stock to “Underweight,” expressing doubt about PayPal’s ability to re-accelerate usage of its branded checkout solution.
Future Growth Levers and the Path Ahead
Alongside the bank charter initiative, PayPal continues to launch new growth projects. Last week, it announced “PayPal World,” a cross-border digital wallet initiative focused on Africa with a planned launch in 2026. The program aims to improve interoperability with local payment methods, tapping into new customer segments in emerging markets.
For now, however, caution dominates trading floors. The stock, trading near €50.95, is hovering close to its recent 52-week low. This represents a decline of approximately 43% from its January peak and a year-to-date drop of nearly 40%. Technically, the share price’s position well below its key moving averages signals a persistent downtrend.
All eyes are now on the Q4 earnings report scheduled for early February 2026. This release will reveal whether the cooling in branded checkout growth is as pronounced as Mizuho anticipates and whether PayPal can demonstrate tangible progress on its strategic banking and growth initiatives. Until then, the narrative remains split: near-term growth concerns weigh on sentiment, while strategically foundational projects like “PayPal Bank” and “PayPal World” are being laid for the years ahead.
Ad
PayPal Stock: Buy or Sell?! New PayPal Analysis from December 22 delivers the answer:
The latest PayPal figures speak for themselves: Urgent action needed for PayPal investors. Is it worth buying or should you sell? Find out what to do now in the current free analysis from December 22.
PayPal: Buy or sell? Read more here...
