A significant shift in sentiment has taken hold on Wall Street regarding digital payments giant PayPal. Over the course of just one week, multiple major financial institutions revised their outlook for the company, with several implementing substantial cuts to their price targets. The primary cause for concern is a notable deceleration in the firm’s core “Branded Checkout” business—the classic payment button. Although management points to long-term strategic investments, market participants are increasingly skeptical about the timeline for a successful operational turnaround.
A Wave of Analyst Downgrades
The current pessimistic outlook was triggered by a series of rating downgrades issued between December 9th and 12th. Bank of America took a particularly definitive stance. Analyst Jason Kupferberg lowered his rating to “Neutral” and slashed his price target from $93 to $68 per share. His rationale carries significant weight: he views the upcoming 2026 fiscal year more as a period of continued investment rather than one where the company will reap substantial rewards.
This cautious perspective was echoed by research firm Baird, which also downgraded the stock on December 12th. The consensus among analysts is strikingly similar. While they acknowledge PayPal’s formidable market position—boasting over 400 million active accounts—and its innovative potential under new leadership, they cite a lack of clear evidence for a sustained recovery in transaction volume growth.
Management Commentary Fuels Apprehension
The analysts’ skepticism is not unfounded; it is supported by recent commentary from PayPal’s own executives. During a business update, Chief Financial Officer Jamie Miller indicated that growth in the critical Branded Checkout segment was likely to moderate in the fourth quarter.
Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying PayPal?
Experts at Compass Point now project that currency-adjusted growth in this division could fall to approximately 2%. This figure sits starkly below previous market expectations of nearly 6%. This growing discrepancy has placed additional pressure on the share price, which has declined roughly 37% since the start of the year and is currently trading just above its 52-week low.
Underlying Strengths Provide Some Support
Despite the prevailing negative tone, several fundamental factors could provide a floor for the stock. Reports of discussions with China’s Ministry of Commerce hint at new potential within the cross-border e-commerce arena. Furthermore, PayPal remains a fundamentally profitable enterprise. Trading at a price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of about 12, its valuation appears moderate in a historical context. The company’s decision to raise its full-year profit guidance following its third-quarter results also demonstrates effective internal cost management.
The crucial test will arrive with the release of fourth-quarter financial results, anticipated in late January or early February of 2026. These figures will reveal whether the current growth softness in PayPal’s core operations is merely a temporary setback or a sign of more profound structural challenges.
Ad
PayPal Stock: Buy or Sell?! New PayPal Analysis from December 14 delivers the answer:
The latest PayPal figures speak for themselves: Urgent action needed for PayPal investors. Is it worth buying or should you sell? Find out what to do now in the current free analysis from December 14.
PayPal: Buy or sell? Read more here...
