Investors in Lynas Rare Earths are navigating turbulent waters following a significant shift in China’s export controls. The diplomatic thaw between the United States and China has triggered a sharp reversal for the Australian mining company’s stock, which has retreated more than 10% in a single week. This pullback interrupts a remarkable rally that had seen the share price more than double since the start of the year, raising questions about the sustainability of its growth narrative.
China’s Strategic Pivot Eases Supply Fears
The catalyst for the sell-off emerged from Beijing, where authorities announced a one-year suspension of stringent rare earths export controls that were initially scheduled for implementation in October. This policy reversal, interpreted as a gesture of goodwill following high-level talks between US and Chinese leaders, signals a temporary de-escalation in trade tensions. While earlier, less restrictive measures from April remain active, the move alleviates immediate concerns about a full-scale supply disruption.
Supporting this shift, Chinese customs data revealed a notable 9% month-over-month increase in rare earths exports for October, breaking a three-month declining trend. Cumulative export volumes for the first ten months of 2025 already stand 10.5% above the same period last year, indicating a substantial loosening of supply constraints in the global market.
Investor Retreat Unravels Previous Gains
The changing landscape has fundamentally altered the investment thesis for Lynas. The company’s impressive performance throughout the year was largely built on expectations that Chinese export restrictions would create supply shortages, thereby boosting demand and prices for non-Chinese producers. With China now demonstrating increased export willingness, the urgency for international buyers to secure alternative supplies from companies like Lynas at premium prices has diminished.
Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying Lynas?
Market participants have responded decisively, engaging in widespread profit-taking that has erased approximately 40% of the stock’s value from its October peak. The extreme volatility—with price swings exceeding 100% year-to-date—underscores the sector’s deep vulnerability to geopolitical developments.
Operational Challenges Compound Market Pressures
Beyond these macro headwinds, Lynas confronts mounting operational concerns. The company recently cast doubt on the future of its flagship US project, a heavy rare earths processing facility in Texas developed in partnership with the Pentagon. Potential delays or cancellation of this strategic initiative would represent a significant setback to the company’s diversification efforts and provide another reason for investor caution.
The competitive environment is also intensifying. Lynas no longer holds a monopoly as the primary Western rare earths supplier. US-based MP Materials currently operates North America’s sole integrated rare earths mine and processing facility, enjoying substantial support from the Department of Defense.
Market observers are now questioning whether Lynas’s earlier surge represented a temporary phenomenon driven by geopolitical speculation, or if the stock will regain momentum as long-term supply security concerns eventually return to the forefront of market attention.
Ad
Lynas Stock: Buy or Sell?! New Lynas Analysis from November 9 delivers the answer:
The latest Lynas figures speak for themselves: Urgent action needed for Lynas investors. Is it worth buying or should you sell? Find out what to do now in the current free analysis from November 9.
Lynas: Buy or sell? Read more here...
