In a move that has sent shockwaves through the mining sector, U.S. silver producer Coeur Mining revealed plans on November 3, 2025, to acquire Canadian competitor New Gold in an all-stock transaction valued at $7 billion. The market’s immediate verdict was harsh, with Coeur’s stock plunging 7% in pre-market trading. While company executives are championing the agreement as transformative, shareholders appear concerned about potential equity dilution rather than value creation.
Market Reaction and Analyst Sentiment
The financial markets responded with notable skepticism to the proposed consolidation. New Gold shares initially climbed 4.9% before retreating from those gains. Coeur Mining securities suffered a more pronounced decline, dropping 7% upon announcement and falling an additional 8.64% in post-earnings pre-market activity.
Financial experts express divided opinions on the strategic move. Some highlight the emergence of a potential top-five global silver producer with enhanced liquidity and prospects for inclusion in major U.S. stock indices. Others point to Coeur’s historical track record with acquisitions and capital raises as a source of uncertainty.
Creating a North American Mining Powerhouse
The combination would fundamentally reshape the competitive landscape, merging two mid-tier producers into a mining heavyweight with operational assets spanning seven mines across the United States, Canada, and Mexico. Financial projections for the merged entity are substantial, with anticipated 2026 EBITDA of $3 billion and free cash flow generation of $2 billion—remarkable figures for a company that reported negative cash flows just two years prior.
The combined production profile presents impressive metrics:
– Annual silver output of 20 million ounces
– Gold production reaching 900,000 ounces annually
– Copper output of 100 million pounds
Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying Coeur Mining?
Under the acquisition terms, New Gold stockholders will receive 0.4959 Coeur shares for each share held, representing a 16% premium to New Gold’s closing price on October 31. Following transaction completion, existing Coeur investors will control 62% of the combined company, with former New Gold shareholders owning the remaining 38%.
Questionable Timing Amid Strong Performance
The acquisition announcement comes at a curious juncture for Coeur Mining. The company recently reported record third-quarter results in late October, showcasing $555 million in revenue, $299 million in EBITDA, and net earnings of $267 million. Cash reserves had more than doubled to $266 million, positioning the company from a place of financial strength.
This robust financial position—with both companies entering a phase of significant cash flow generation—makes the decision to pursue a substantially dilutive transaction particularly noteworthy. The merged entity would command a market capitalization of approximately $20 billion. Should the transaction fail to receive necessary approvals, termination fees of $414 million from Coeur and $255 million from New Gold would apply.
The completion timeline targets the first half of 2026, pending shareholder approvals from both corporations and regulatory clearances. Whether this massive consolidation ultimately creates shareholder value or merely dilutes existing ownership remains the critical question facing investors.
Ad
Coeur Mining Stock: Buy or Sell?! New Coeur Mining Analysis from November 4 delivers the answer:
The latest Coeur Mining figures speak for themselves: Urgent action needed for Coeur Mining investors. Is it worth buying or should you sell? Find out what to do now in the current free analysis from November 4.
Coeur Mining: Buy or sell? Read more here...
